Smart Lock Face-Off: August vs Schlage

When upgrading your home security, a smart lock is one of the best investments you can make. Two of the most prominent names in the market—August and Schlage—offer strong but very different options. In this detailed comparison, we break down their design philosophies, installation complexity, smart integrations, security features, and more to help you decide which one is right for your smart home setup.

🔍 Overview: Who Are These For?

August Smart Lock (4th Gen with Wi-Fi Bridge):
Best for renters or homeowners who want a sleek, invisible retrofit with strong app support. Ideal if you want to keep your existing deadbolt hardware while gaining remote access and automation.

Schlage Encode Smart WiFi Deadbolt:
Great for homeowners who want a keypad lock with built-in Wi-Fi, no bridge, and enterprise-grade security. Perfect for short-term rental hosts, busy families, or anyone who prefers code-based access over smartphone unlocking.

🔧 Installation: Retrofit vs Replacement

August

• Install Time: ~10 minutes
• Tools Required: None (basic screwdriver optional)
• Process: Mounts inside over the existing deadbolt thumbturn.
• Skill Level: Beginner-friendly; no door modification needed.

The August lock excels here. You keep your existing deadbolt (and keys), and the smart unit simply attaches over the interior lock. No drilling or replacing parts. Ideal for renters or anyone hesitant about permanent changes.

Schlage

• Install Time: ~25–30 minutes
• Tools Required: Screwdriver, possibly chisel (for some older doors)
• Process: Complete removal of the old deadbolt; installs a full smart deadbolt.
• Skill Level: Intermediate. Not hard, but more hands-on.

Schlage requires you to fully replace your door's lock, including the latch and strike plate. The payoff is a fully integrated, tamper-resistant unit with a keypad and built-in Wi-Fi.

✅ Winner: August (for ease)
🏆 Winner: Schlage (for robustness)

🎨 Design & Aesthetics

August

• Appearance: Round, minimalist disc with aluminum finish
• Visible from outside?: No—looks like a regular keyhole
• Color Options: Silver, black

Schlage

• Appearance: Traditional keypad with touchscreen and keyhole
• Visible from outside?: Yes—keypad and branding are front and center
• Color Options: Aged bronze, satin nickel, matte black

August blends in seamlessly—no one will know it's a smart lock unless they’re inside. Schlage, meanwhile, makes its presence known and projects a secure, high-tech look from the curb.

✅ Winner: Depends on taste

• Discreet? Go August
• Bold and secure? Go Schlage

📱 App & Smart Home Integration

August

• App Experience: Polished and intuitive
• Integration:
  • Apple HomeKit ✅
  • Google Assistant ✅
  • Amazon Alexa ✅
  • Samsung SmartThings ❌
• Remote Access: Via Wi-Fi Bridge (included with 4th Gen)
• Automation: Auto-lock/unlock, guest invites, notifications

Schlage

• App Experience: Solid, slightly less modern
• Integration:
  • Amazon Alexa ✅
  • Google Assistant ✅
  • Apple HomeKit ❌ (unless paired with 3rd-party hub like HomeBridge)
• Remote Access: Native Wi-Fi—no bridge needed
• Automation: Code scheduling, lock notifications, built-in alarm system

August wins on ecosystem flexibility, especially for Apple users. But Schlage’s Wi-Fi built-in model is more convenient—no bridge, no pairing headaches.

✅ Winner: August (Apple users); Schlage (simplicity and Wi-Fi built-in)

🔒 Security and Reliability

August

• Lock Hardware: Relies on your existing deadbolt
• Security Rating: Depends on deadbolt used
• Digital Features:
  • Two-factor authentication
  • Activity log
  • DoorSense sensor (detects whether door is fully closed)

Schlage

• Lock Hardware: ANSI/BHMA Grade 1 certified (top-tier)
• Security Rating: Best in class for residential use
• Digital Features:
  • Built-in alarm
  • Up to 100 access codes
  • Code schedule and expiration
  • Tamper and forced-entry detection

If you prioritize physical security, Schlage is hands-down the better choice. Its ANSI Grade 1 certification, built-in keypad, and alarm system offer real protection against break-ins.

✅ Winner: Schlage

🧠 Smart Features Comparison

🏁 Final Verdict

💡 Bottom Line

• Choose August if you’re looking for a sleek retrofit that plays nicely with Apple HomeKit and supports flexible automation.

• Choose Schlage Encode if you want the most secure smart lock with keypad entry, no bridge needed, and robust Wi-Fi control built-in.

Both are excellent options—but your lifestyle and smart home ecosystem will determine the best fit.